I’ve been driving since 2005 and in October, 2017, I purchased my tenth vehicle. In those 13 years of motoring, I very nearly averaged a different car a year, but here’s the truth: some cars only lasted three months while others lasted seven years. Some were crashed and totaled – a consequence of my naive and exuberant youth. Others were sold, either due to boredom or necessity.
Looking at the list, there’s a clear pattern in my affinity: cumbersome, utilitarian four-wheel-drive “tractors” masquerading as passenger cars. I’ve owned five Subaru station wagons and three Jeep Cherokee XJs. The other two – the literal black sheep of the fleet – easily rank highest on the quintessential gearhead score card, but I never really mixed well with those types.
In ranking my past, I’m going to do so on two levels: subjectively, i.e. my personal favoritism, and objectively, i.e. which cars were/are actually good. One was pretty easy to determine – the other not so much. What makes a good car anyways? Is it reliability? Value? Utility? Flexibility? Efficiency? Performance? Prestige? Aesthetics? The way I see it, looking at these cars objectively requires placing yourself in the minds and number crunching hearts of a Consumer Reports vehicle tester. Who’s your audience? The average consumer of course.
Obviously, subjectivity is more entertaining than an objective analysis, so without further adieu, here is the definitive, subjective ranking of the 10 cars I’ve owned – with a little objectivity thrown in for good measure.
Continue reading →